Dealing With an Italian Estate Agency: Who They Work For and What You Sign
How Italian estate agents work: paid by both sides, commission due when your offer is accepted, and why the purchase offer at the agency is a binding document.
For most foreign buyers, the first real contact with the Italian property market is an estate agency. The listing looks familiar, the agent is helpful, the visit goes well, and within days you are asked to sign a “proposta d’acquisto”, a purchase offer, with a deposit cheque.
That moment is where most expensive mistakes are made. The Italian agency system works differently from the American or British one, and the offer you sign at the agency is far more binding than it looks. This guide explains how agencies work in Italy and how to deal with them safely.
Who the Agent Works For
In the United States, buyer and seller usually have separate agents. In Italy, the agent is typically a mediatore: a neutral intermediary who brings the parties together and is paid by both. The law requires the agent to be impartial and to disclose the circumstances they know that could affect the deal, but the agent is not your adviser. Their income depends on the sale happening.
That is not a criticism; many Italian agents are excellent professionals. But it means that the checks that protect you, on the property, the price and the contract, are your responsibility. Many international buyers therefore use a buyer’s search agent, who works only for them, and a lawyer who acts only for you.
The Commission: How Much and When
Agency fees in Italy are not fixed by law. In most cities they range from about 2% to 4% of the price, plus 22% VAT, charged to both buyer and seller; for low-value properties a fixed minimum is common. Fees are negotiable, and it is worth agreeing them in writing before the first visit.
The crucial point is timing. Under the Civil Code, the agent is entitled to the commission when the deal is “concluded”, and the courts consider a deal concluded when the parties are bound, typically when your purchase offer is accepted by the seller. If you later change your mind, you may lose your deposit and still owe the commission. The commission paid, and the agent’s details, are also declared in the final notarial deed.
The Purchase Offer: Small Form, Big Consequences
The proposta irrevocabile d’acquisto is usually a pre-printed form provided by the agency. You offer a price, attach a deposit and commit not to withdraw for a set period. If the seller accepts and you are informed, the offer can become a binding preliminary agreement. Its terms then shape everything that follows: deposit, deadlines for the preliminary contract and the deed, what happens if problems emerge.
A well-drafted offer includes conditions that protect you: that the property conforms to planning and cadastral records, that there are no mortgages or liens, that the condominium has no unpaid works, and, if you need one, that you obtain a mortgage. Agency forms rarely include these by default. You can and should ask for them to be added.
How to Work With an Agency Safely
None of this slows a good deal down. A lawyer can usually review a purchase offer within a day or two, and a reputable agent will accept reasonable conditions. If an agent pushes you to sign immediately “because another buyer is interested”, that is precisely the moment to slow down.
After the Offer
Once the offer is accepted, the usual next steps are the preliminary contract, often with a larger deposit, and then the final deed before a notary. Each stage has its own risks and costs, including the purchase taxes, which depend on whether the home will be your main residence. Our guide on how to buy a house in Italy follows the whole process, and our guide for foreigners buying covers the issues specific to non-residents, such as buying remotely with a power of attorney.
Our View
Italian agents can open doors you would never find alone, and many are excellent. But they are intermediaries, not advisers, and the system puts the decisive commitment, the purchase offer, at the very beginning. Treat the offer as the contract it can become: check first, then sign.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do estate agents charge in Italy?
Usually about 2% to 4% of the price plus 22% VAT, charged to both buyer and seller. Fees are not fixed by law and can be negotiated.
Does the buyer pay the estate agent in Italy?
Yes, in most cases. Italian agents typically act as intermediaries for both parties and are paid by both.
When is the agent's commission due in Italy?
When the deal is concluded, which the courts usually consider to be when the purchase offer is accepted, not at the final deed.
Is a purchase offer binding in Italy?
An irrevocable purchase offer binds you for its validity period, and once accepted by the seller it can become a binding agreement to buy.
How can I check an Italian estate agent?
Ask for their registration number with the Chamber of Commerce; only registered agents are entitled to a commission.


